Department of Communication Studies, University of Nevada, Reno, USA
*Corresponding author:Jimmie Manning, Department of Communication Studies, University of Nevada, Reno, Reno, Nevada, USA
Submission: October 22, 2026;Published: November 16, 2026
ISSN 2637-7632Volume8 Issue 3
Academic citations are generally presented as orderly acknowledgments of intellectual debt, yet their communicative consequences extend beyond accurate attribution. This conceptual essay examines citation as a relational practice through which scholars construct identities, distribute recognition, negotiate power, and position others within academic communities. Drawing on communication as constitutive of relationships, relational-identity theory, and Gunn’s coprophilic critique of scholarly respectability, it introduces shitation: citational action in which appropriate relevance or acknowledgment is displaced, distorted, or neglected by relational, strategic, institutional, or epistemic processes. An intentionally excessive self-citation preface demonstrates how the same bibliographic practice can invite incompatible interpretations of expertise, generosity, narcissism, status, and scholarly legitimacy. The essay then develops a provisional typology of fourteen forms of shitation organized into five families: affiliation and recognition, status and self-presentation, coercion, epistemic distortion, and informal invocation. These forms include exclusionary omissions, retaliatory acknowledgment, self-promotional citation, coercive reference demands, misrepresentation, and hallucinated scholarship. Extending a gastrointestinal metaphor of intellectual consumption, digestion, circulation, and waste, the essay argues that a formally pristine reference list can conceal consequential relational politics. Rather than promising perfectly hygienic citation or diagnosing authorial motives from citation counts, it advocates relational accountability to cited scholars, readers, and the communities constituted through scholarly recognition and its absence.
Keywords: Shitation; Academic citation; Scholarly communication; Interpersonal communication; Relational identity; Citation ethics; Intellectual recognition; Academic publishing; Relational accountability; Gastrointestinal metaphor
Abbreviations: AI: Artificial Intelligence; CCR: Communication as Constitutive of Relationships; COPE: Committee on Publication Ethics; ICMJE: International Committee of Medical Journal Editors
a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Based on a work at www.crimsonpublishers.com.
Best viewed in