The Rise of Integrative Veterinary Medicine: Use of Cam in Animal Healthcare

In recent decades, veterinary medicine has experienced a significant paradigm shift, adapting to the advancements in scientific knowledge and technology, as well as an increasing recognition of the intricate requirements of animal patients [1]. An unprecedented development in the field of veterinary medicine is the emergence of Integrative Veterinary Medicine (IVM), an all-encompassing strategy that merges traditional Western medicine with Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) in order to enhance the well-being of animals [2]. The expansive use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) modalities, including but not limited to acupuncture, herbal medicine, chiropractic, and homeopathy, in the treatment, management, and prevention of animal maladies, were reviewed as part of the integrative strategies within veterinary medicine [3].

Integrative Veterinary Medicine signifies more than a simple comparison between conventional and alternative therapies; rather, it embodies a deliberate convergence that places significant emphasis on delivering individualized healthcare for animals [1]. A thorough comprehension of the interplay between the body, mind, and environment of the animal, as well as the ways in which these components impact health and disease, is imperative. In dissecting the philosophical foundations of IVM, this article emphasizes the significance of a patient-centric approach that values the empirical knowledge inherent in CAM practices as well as the science-based methodologies of Western veterinary medicine [4].

Reflecting pet owner preferences, empirical successes of integrative treatments, and a growing body of research that endeavors to evaluate the efficacy and safety of various CAM modalities, the burgeoning use of CAM in veterinary medicine is motivated by a variety of factors. As the bond between humans and animals strengthens, there is a corresponding demand for healthcare that reflects the holistic approach that humans take towards themselves. This includes preventive and wellness strategies that go beyond traditional diagnostics and treatments [5,6].

This review presented clinical evidence, practice patterns, and the potential for CAM to cover gaps in conventional veterinary care in order to provide a critical analysis of the current state of knowledge regarding IVM. The challenge of integrating CAM into conventional veterinary medicine would also be addressed, encompassing concerns related to standardization, professional acceptability, and evidentiary support and would also contribute to the ongoing dialogue regarding the role of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in veterinary medicine and lay the groundwork for future research and application in the field.

Integrative Veterinary Medicine (IVM) signifies a fundamental transformation in the approach to animal healthcare, transcending the mere convergence of treatment modalities.

Holism vs. reductionism

The conventional paradigm in veterinary medicine has frequently been marked by reductionism, an approach that oversimplifies intricate biological systems to their elemental constituents. Although considerable progress has been made in particular treatments and surgical procedures as a result, this approach may fail to consider the interdependence between biological systems, the environment, and the behavior of the animal [7]. Conversely, IVM is founded upon the principles of holistic philosophy. The proposition asserts that animals transcend their physiological components and possess sentience, encompassing intricate physical, mental, emotional, and occasionally spiritual requirements that collectively influence their overall well-being [8].

The bio-psycho-social-spiritual model

The bio-psycho-social-spiritual model, which extends beyond the biological dimension of animal health to encompass psychological well-being, social interactions, and spiritual harmony for certain individuals, is frequently mentioned by IVM practitioners. This particular model acknowledges that palpable impacts on an animal’s physical health can result from stress, loneliness, or anxiety. Therefore, environmental enrichment, behavioral therapy, and socialization may be incorporated into integrative veterinary practice alongside pharmacology and surgery [9,10].

Prevention regarding cure

An additional fundamental tenet of the IVM philosophy is its prioritization of prevention over mere treatment. In contrast to conventional medicine, which frequently intervenes when an ailment or injury has already occurred, IVM promotes a preventive stance that bolsters the body’s inherent defenses and fosters resistance to disease. Nutrition, for example, is considered a fundamental component of preventive health and not merely a matter of dietary choice [11].

Personalized care

IVM holds that a one-size-fits-all approach is diametrically opposed to the fact that each animal is unique. The provision of personalized care entails the customization of remedies to suit the unique requirements, situations, and preferences of each individual. This may entail a blend of conventional and alternative therapies tailored to the specific needs of the individual in order to promote their optimal health [12].

Multiple knowledge system integration

IVM serves as an assembly place for various knowledge systems. In addition to valuing the scientific rigor and empirical evidence of conventional medicine, it recognizes the historical validity and wisdom of alternative practices such as acupuncture and herbal medicine. Although not in opposition to Western medicine, this inclusive approach aims to supplement it with alternative viewpoints and methodologies [13].

Compassion and Interdependence

IVM practitioners frequently perceive themselves as interconnected with the animals they care for and the environment they inhabit, constituting a larger ecosystem. This perspective cultivates a profound sense of compassion and empathy, propelled by a dedication to providing considerate and respectful care. This viewpoint is highly congruent with the principles held by numerous animal enthusiasts and pet owners, who consider their canine companions to be members of the family that require comprehensive care rather than mere possessions [14].

Integrative Veterinary Medicine (IVM) is an area of practice that incorporates various Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) techniques with the aim of augmenting the quality of animal healthcare. These therapies are frequently integrated with conventional medicine in order to develop an all-encompassing treatment regimen that attends to multiple facets of an animal’s well-being. A description of several CAM modalities utilized in IVM follows [1].

The practice of acupuncture

Acupuncture, which has its origins in traditional Chinese medicine, generates a therapeutic effect through the insertion of extremely fine needles into specific sites on the body. It is utilized to enhance function, alleviate pain, and promote recovery in animals. Acupuncturists in veterinary medicine frequently treat ailments such as arthritis, nerve damage, gastrointestinal disorders, and chronic discomfort. Numerous studies have provided evidence supporting the effectiveness of acupuncture in animals, emphasizing its analgesic and anti-inflammatory properties [15].

Herbal treatment

Herbal medicine treats a wide range of maladies with substances derived from plants. Herbs may be utilized in veterinary medicine for their pharmacological properties, which may include anti-inflammatory, antimicrobial, or organ function assistance. One illustration of this is the frequent utilization of milk thistle to promote liver health, whereas echinacea is sometimes employed to fortify the immune system. To guarantee the secure administration of these treatments, veterinary pharmacognosy expertise is necessary for the treatment of herbal medication [16].

Chiropractic treatment

Without resorting to medication or surgery, veterinary chiropractic care focuses on the preservation of the spinal column, discs, associated nerves, and bone geometry. Restoring mobility, relieving pain, and enhancing nervous system function are all objectives that can yield extensive health advantages. Certain chronic musculoskeletal disorders, intervertebral disc disease, and hip dysplasia are frequent conditions to which it is applied [17].

The homeopathic

Homeopathy operates under the principle of “like cures like,” which entails the use of extremely diluted formulations of substances capable of inducing symptoms in a healthy animal in order to alleviate comparable symptoms in an ill animal. This modality is frequently the subject of controversy and debate as a result of the substantial dilution of substances employed, which detractors contend exceeds the threshold of molecular presence. Advocates of homeopathy, on the other hand, assert that their products can effectively stimulate the body’s innate healing mechanisms [18].

Nutritional treatment

In IVM, nutritional therapy places significant emphasis on the role of diet in both disease prevention and treatment. Potential strategies for maintaining health during different stages of disease include the utilization of specialized diets, supplementation, or the integration of particular nutrients that are recognized to promote well-being. One illustration of this is the frequent recommendation of omega-3 fatty acids due to their anti-inflammatory characteristics, while the utilization of antioxidants can provide assistance to animals afflicted with chronic ailments [19].

Treatment of the Physical

Physical therapy is comparable to physical rehabilitation in the field of veterinary medicine. To enhance functionality and mobility, it encompasses a variety of treatments, including therapeutic exercises, neuromuscular re-education, and modalities such as ultrasound or electrical stimulation. Animals recovering from trauma, postoperative patients, and those afflicted with degenerative diseases can all benefit significantly from rehabilitation [20].

Hydrotherapy

By avoiding joint tension, hydrotherapy provides therapeutic benefits, including pain relief and enhanced muscle tone, through the use of water. This is especially beneficial for canines afflicted with arthritis or those undergoing recovery from surgery or injury. Whirlpools and underwater treadmills, which combine resistance and buoyancy, are utilized to aid in rehabilitation [21].

Body-mind therapies

In veterinary medicine, mind-body therapies, including Reiki and animal massage, are founded on the premise that the psyche can influence physical health. The purpose of these therapies is to induce relaxation, reduce tension, and enhance general health. Although the effectiveness of certain modalities is not substantiated by substantial scientific evidence, anecdotal evidence indicates that they may enhance the quality of life for certain animals [21].

An emerging discipline, Integrative Veterinary Medicine (IVM) integrates complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) with traditional veterinary practices in order to provide a comprehensive approach to the well-being of animals. Nevertheless, similar to any burgeoning field that deviates from conventional frameworks, IVM encounters a multitude of obstacles and factors to be taken into account. The following are several fundamental concerns.

Control and standardization of quality

IVM encounters a significant obstacle in the form of nonstandardization among CAM modalities. There are numerous alternative therapies for which there is no universally acknowledged dosage, protocol, or treatment regimen. This may result in operational incongruities and challenges in guaranteeing quality assurance. Furthermore, in comparison to conventional medicine, the regulatory framework governing numerous CAM treatments is frequently less stringent, which raises concerns regarding the safety and quality of herbal products, supplements, and other nontraditional remedies [22].

Practice based on evidence

A considerable proportion of IVM, specifically CAM, is deficient in high-quality research to substantiate its effectiveness. Systematic evaluations and Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs) are frequently regarded as the gold standard for evidence in the scientific community. However, many CAM therapies have not been subjected to this level of scrutiny, which may cause traditionally trained veterinarians to be skeptical and reluctant to incorporate these practices [23].

Skepticism that permeates the veterinary discipline

There are still veterinarians who maintain skepticism regarding the integration of CAM into clinical practice. This skepticism is frequently grounded in the scientific method, which places emphasis on empirical and quantifiable evidence. Resistance may be directed at CAM therapies that have not undergone comprehensive scientific investigation or are founded upon principles that remain partially elucidated by Western science. Those interested in IVM may be deprived of mentorship and training opportunities due to this division [23].

Economic factors to consider

Economic obstacles could potentially confront integrative practices, including the financial burdens linked to the procurement and prescription of non-traditional therapies, specialized apparatus investments, and staff training expansion. Additionally, insurance reimbursement and recognition for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) treatments may be comparatively limited in comparison to conventional veterinary services. This can impose financial burdens on both the CAM practice and the pet owners [24].

Welfare and ethical considerations

Veterinary professionals are confronted with the ethical quandary of CAM treatment considerations. This encompasses guaranteeing that treatments are non-adverse, operate in the animal’s best interest, and do not supplant or postpone the implementation of established conventional treatments when they are required. Additionally, it is ethically responsible to address the expectations and beliefs of proprietors regarding CAM while ensuring that informed consent is consistently acquired [25].

Inter-disciplinary dialogue

IVM necessitates proficient communication and cooperative efforts from a heterogeneous group of experts, comprising practitioners with backgrounds in both conventional medicine and a multitude of CAM disciplines. The integration of multiple disciplines may encounter challenges stemming from divergent terminologies, treatment philosophies, and educational contexts, which may result in misinterpretations and fragmented healthcare.

Education deficits

Regarding IVM and CAM, veterinary institutions lack adequate instruction. Although certain universities are starting to integrate these subjects into their academic programs, a significant number of veterinary graduates possess limited or no formal training in these domains. As a consequence, the workforce may be inadequately equipped to address the increasing need for integrative care alternatives from clients [26].

Aspects of regulation and law

The IVM regulatory environment is intricate and significantly differs across jurisdictions. The application of diverse CAM therapies is governed by an intricate web of local, state, and national regulations that practitioners must traverse. There may be instances where the legality of particular CAM modalities is ambiguous, posing potential dangers for veterinary professionals.

Integrative Veterinary Medicine advocates for a holistic treatment paradigm in animal healthcare by integrating a range of complementary and alternative therapies with conventional medical procedures. Our research has explored the complex characteristics of IVM, including an analysis of its philosophical underpinnings, the wide range of treatment modalities it incorporates, and the obstacles it encounters, including the requirement for universally accepted evidence-based practices and greater recognition within the veterinary field. Notwithstanding these challenges, IVM remains gaining momentum, propelled by an expanding inclination among pet owners and practitioners towards holistic healthcare that holds the potential to improve the health and standard of living of animal patients. Consistent progress in IVM will necessitate comprehensive endeavors in education, research, and regulation; nevertheless, its capacity to fundamentally transform the field of veterinary medicine remains auspicious and significant.

1. Memon MA, Shmalberg J, Adair HS, Allweiler S, Bryan JN, et al. (2016) Integrative veterinary medical education and consensus guidelines for an integrative veterinary medicine curriculum within veterinary colleges. Open Vet J 6(1): 44-56.
2. Caneschi A, Bardhi A, Barbarossa A, Zaghini A (2023) The use of antibiotics and antimicrobial resistance in veterinary medicine, a complex phenomenon: A narrative review. Antibiotics 12(3): 487.
3. Arlt S, Heuwieser W (2010) Evidence-based complementary and alternative veterinary medicine-a contradiction in terms? Berl Munch Tierarztl Wochenschr 123(9-10): 377-384.
4. Pun JK (2020) An integrated review of the role of communication in veterinary clinical practice. BMC Vet Res 16(1): 394.
5. Gyles C (2020) Complementary and alternative veterinary medicine. Can Vet J 61(4): 345-346.
6. Mills DS (2022) Clinical animal behaviour: Paradigms, problems and practice. Animals 12(22): 3103.
7. Mahmoudi S, Jafari E, Nasrabadi HA, Liaghatdar MJ (2012) Holistic education: An approach for 21^st Int Educ Stud 5(2): 178.
8. Saad M, Medeiros R, Mosini AC (2017) Are we ready for a true biopsychosocial-spiritual model? The many meanings of "spiritual". Medicines 4(4): 79.
9. Galbadage T, Peterson BM, Wang DC, Wang JS, Gunasekera RS (2020) Biopsychosocial and spiritual implications of patients with COVID-19 dying in isolation. Front Psychol 11: 588623.
10. Young CE, Roncisvalle CA (2001) Expenditures, investment and financing for sustainable development in Brazil. Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC).
11. Dwivedi YK, Hughes L, Baabdullah AM, Navarrete SR, Giannakis M, et al. (2022) Metaverse beyond the hype: Multidisciplinary perspectives on emerging challenges, opportunities and agenda for research, practice and policy. Int J Inf Manag 66: 102542.
12. Al-Riyami H, Al-Maskari A, Nadar SK, Almaskari M (2023) Knowledge, attitudes and practices regarding traditional and complimentary medicine in Oman. Sultan Qaboos Univ Med J 23(1):90-98.
13. Alikhani S, Nummi P, Ojala A (2021) Urban wetlands: A review on ecological and cultural values. Water 13(22): 3301.
14. Harrison TM, Churgin SM (2022) Acupuncture and traditional Chinese veterinary medicine in zoological and exotic animal medicine: A review and introduction of methods. Vet Sci 9(2): 74.
15. Khazaei R, Seidavi A, Bouyeh M (2022) A review on the mechanisms of the effect of silymarin in milk thistle (Silybum marianum) on some laboratory animals. Vet Med Sci 8(1): 289-301.
16. Maltese PE, Michelini S, Baronio M, Bertelli M (2019) Molecular foundations of chiropractic therapy. Acta Biomed 90(10-S): 93-102.
17. Marotti I, Betti L, Bregola V, Bosi S, Trebbi G, et al. (2014) Transcriptome profiling of wheat seedlings following treatment with ultrahigh diluted arsenic trioxide. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2014: 851263.
18. Cencic A, Chingwaru W (2010) The role of functional foods, nutraceuticals, and food supplements in intestinal health. Nutrients 2(6): 611-625.
19. Mille MA, McClement J, Lauer S (2022) Physiotherapeutic strategies and their current evidence for canine osteoarthritis. Vet Sci 10(1): 2.
20. Formenton MR, Pereira MAA, Fantoni DT (2017) Small animal massage therapy: A brief review and relevant observations. Top Companion Anim Med 32(4): 139-145.
21. Tabish SA (2008) Complementary and alternative healthcare: is it evidence-based? Int J Health Sci (Qassim) 2(1): V-IX.
22. Chiappelli F, Prolo P, Rosenblum M, Edgerton M, Cajulis OS (2006) Evidence-based research in complementary and alternative medicine II: the process of evidence-based research. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 3(1): 3-12.
23. Ventola CL (2010) Current issues regarding Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) in the United States: Part 1: The widespread use of CAM and the need for better-informed health care professionals to provide patient counseling 35(8): 461-468.
24. Quain A, Ward MP, Mullan S (2021) Ethical challenges posed by advanced veterinary care in companion animal veterinary practice. Animals (Basel) 11(11): 3010.
25. Rösch T, Schaper E, Tipold A, Fischer M, Dilly M, et al. (2014) Clinical skills of veterinary students-a cross-sectional study of the self-concept and exposure to skills training in Hannover, Germany. BMC Vet Res 21:10: 969.
26. Nadareishvili I, Pkhakadze G, Japiashvili N, Lunze K (2021) Regulatory environment for complementary and alternative medicine in Georgia-a health policy analysis. Int J Health Plann Manage 36(4): 1038-1051.