AI-Driven Solutions for Cost-Effective Spine Surgery: A Comparative Analysis of Military vs. Civilian Healthcare Practices

Spine surgery is a critical aspect of both military and civilian healthcare systems, encompassing a range of procedures, from trauma surgery to elective treatments for chronic conditions such as degenerative disc disease or scoliosis. These surgeries require precise decision-making, optimal resource allocation, and efficient use of healthcare personnel and equipment. In military healthcare facilities, spine surgery often involves managing high-acuity trauma patients and operational constraints, such as limited access to specialized care in field settings. Conversely, civilian healthcare systems are challenged with managing high patient volumes, insurance limitations, and rising costs.

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly emerging as a transformative tool in healthcare, particularly in enhancing the efficiency, precision, and cost-effectiveness of spine surgeries. AI-driven solutions, including machine learning models for patient diagnosis and robotic-assisted surgery, hold promise for addressing both clinical and cost-related challenges in spine surgery across diverse healthcare settings. This review aims to analyze the current practices in spine surgery within military and civilian healthcare systems, explore the potential roles of AI in enhancing care delivery, and provide insights into how AI can be leveraged to create cost-efficient care models for spine surgery.

Military healthcare system

The U.S. military healthcare system, through the Department of Defense (DoD), provides comprehensive care to active-duty service members, veterans, and their families. The system is characterized by a unique patient population, including young, otherwise healthy individuals who experience traumatic injuries, such as spine injuries from combat, accidents, and training exercises [1]. Rapid, high-quality spine surgical interventions are often required in these cases. However, military hospitals, particularly those in combat zones or remote areas, frequently face significant resource constraints, including limited access to advanced technologies, reduced staff availability, and challenges related to the sustainability of care over long deployments [2].

Military spine surgeons are highly trained to manage complex trauma cases, relying on advanced surgical techniques in emergency settings. Nonetheless, military healthcare facilities face long wait times for elective surgeries, limited access to specialized neurosurgeons, and logistical challenges in post-operative rehabilitation [3].

Civilian healthcare system

In the civilian sector, spine surgery is available through hospitals, specialty clinics, and outpatient surgery centers. The U.S. civilian healthcare system serves a diverse population, treating a wide range of spine conditions, including trauma, degenerative diseases, and congenital spine disorders. While civilian hospitals typically have access to more advanced technologies and specialized care compared to military facilities, they face significant challenges related to cost management, patient volume, and treatment outcome variability Tominari et al., 2019. Despite advances in surgical techniques and improved patient outcomes, the civilian sector struggles with rising healthcare costs. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) reports that spine surgery is one of the most costly procedures, contributing significantly to the financial burden of healthcare systems, particularly in post-surgical rehabilitation, hospital readmissions, and long-term care [4].

AI for preoperative planning and decision support

AI has the potential to revolutionize preoperative planning in spine surgery by utilizing data from medical imaging (e.g., MRI, CT scans) to create personalized surgical plans. Machine learning algorithms can assist surgeons in diagnosing complex spine conditions by identifying patterns in patient data that may not be immediately obvious. AI systems such as SpineX and other machine learning models have shown promise in predicting surgical outcomes, determining the risk of complications, and recommending optimal treatment pathways [5]. AI can also integrate various data sources-clinical notes, lab results, imaging, and even patientreported outcomes-into real-time decision-making frameworks for spine surgeons, which can reduce variability in treatment decisions and ensure that patients receive the most appropriate care tailored to their specific needs Ravi et al., 2020.

AI in minimizing surgical errors and improving precision

AI-powered robotic-assisted spine surgery is gaining traction in both military and civilian settings. These AI-guided systems improve surgical precision by assisting surgeons with delicate tasks such as placing spinal screws or conducting minimally invasive procedures. Studies have shown that robotic surgery improves surgical accuracy, reduces human error, and shortens recovery times [6]; Patel et al., 2020. In military settings, AI-guided robotics can be particularly useful in battlefield hospitals or field surgical units, where resources may be limited [7].

Optimizing resource allocation and cost reduction

AI can optimize resource utilization in spine surgery, especially in military healthcare settings. By analyzing historical data, AI can predict peak demand periods, optimize operating room scheduling, and reduce unnecessary tests or procedures, ultimately improving cost-efficiency Singh et al., 2020. Predictive models can also help prioritize surgical cases based on urgency and medical need. Additionally, AI can assist in managing surgical instruments, ensuring that necessary tools are available and sterilized on time, which is essential in resource-constrained environments like military hospitals [8]. In civilian settings, AI models can streamline administrative tasks, reducing the administrative burden on healthcare providers and lowering overhead costs associated with spine surgery.

AI for postoperative monitoring and rehabilitation

Postoperative care is critical in spine surgery, particularly for patients recovering from complex spinal injuries or traumatic injuries. AI-powered monitoring systems utilizing wearable devices can track vital signs, mobility, and pain levels, transmitting real-time data to healthcare providers Taha et al., 2021. These systems can alert clinicians to early signs of complications such as infections or pressure sores, facilitating timely interventions. In rehabilitation, AI can help design personalized recovery plans using data from wearable sensors and patient feedback. This approach is particularly beneficial in military settings, where rehabilitation may take place in remote or non-traditional care environments.

While AI integration offers clear advantages for spine surgery in both military and civilian healthcare systems, challenges remain, including technological adoption, costs, and infrastructure. In military healthcare, resource constraints and logistical challenges may limit the full implementation of AI-driven technologies. However, AI’s ability to optimize resource allocation and improve surgical precision is particularly valuable in ensuring high-quality care in austere environments [1,9].

In civilian healthcare, AI solutions can help alleviate the pressures faced by spine surgery departments, such as high patient volumes and cost constraints. Recent reviews have highlighted the growing applications of AI in preoperative planning, intraoperative navigation, and postoperative outcome prediction in spine surgery [9,10]. Successful implementation of AI requires overcoming barriers, such as data privacy concerns, regulatory approval, and the initial technology investment [3]. Moreover, AI should be integrated thoughtfully into clinical workflows to complement-rather than replace-the judgment of experienced healthcare providers.

AI holds significant promise for improving the cost-efficiency and quality of spine surgery in both military and civilian healthcare settings. By enhancing preoperative planning, minimizing surgical errors, optimizing resource utilization, and improving postoperative care, AI can address several longstanding challenges in spine surgery. While challenges regarding the integration of AI remain, continued advancements in technology and targeted investment can pave the way for more cost-effective, higher-quality care in the future.

1. Bowers J, O'Rourke J, McKinley M (2020) Spinal trauma care in military settings: Current approaches and future directions. Military Health System Review 47(3): 101-108.
2. Kincaid M, Wilson G, Smith R (2021) Challenges and innovations in spine surgery within the military healthcare system. Journal of Military Orthopedics 14(2): 85-92.
3. McKinley M (2019) Improving cost-efficiency in spine surgery: The role of artificial intelligence in healthcare systems. Journal of Healthcare Management 28(2): 245-258.
4. Olson A (2020) Financial impacts of spine surgery in the U.S.: Economic burden and healthcare policy implications. Journal of Spine Research 19(4): 234-239.
5. Lee J, Lee S, Choi J (2021) AI in preoperative spine surgery: Current trends and future potential. Spine Journal 21(3): 123-130.
6. Park J, Kim Y, Lee M (2019) The impact of robotic-assisted surgery in spine surgery.
7. Baldwin J, Dwyer A (2020) The role of robotic-assisted surgery in military healthcare: Opportunities and challenges. Journal of Military Medicine 186(5): 292-299.
8. Cohen L, Stewart M (2021) Artificial intelligence in surgery: Improving resource efficiency in military and civilian healthcare systems. Journal of Surgical Innovation 13(4): 230-240.
9. Kalanjiyam GP, Chandramohan T, Raman M, Kalyanasundaram H (2024) Artificial intelligence: A new cutting-edge tool in spine surgery. Asian Spine J 18(3): 458-471.
10. Shi L, Wang H, Shea GKH (2025) The application of artificial intelligence in spine surgery: A scoping review. J Am Acad Orthop Surg Glob Res Rev 9(4): e24.00405.