Maksymchuk IM1*, Khriplyviy AO1, Frieze VV1, Romanko PM1, Khokhlova JA2 and Khokhlov MA2
1IM Frantsevich Institute for Problems of Materials Science, NAS of Ukraine, Ukraine
2EO Paton Electric Welding Institute, NAS of Ukraine, Ukraine
*Corresponding author: Maksymchuk IM, IM Frantsevich Institute for Problems of Materials Science, NAS of Ukraine, Ukraine
Submission: March 18, 2020;Published: April 03, 2020
ISSN: 2576-8840 Volume 13 Issue 1
The specific features of the crystallization kinetics of the ternary Al-Ni-Fe system due to the order of the introduction of the alloying elements are explained in terms of the cluster structure of the melts of binary metal systems Al-Ni and Al-Fe. It was established that the order of introduction of the alloying elements into the aluminum melt determines the formation of a different cluster structure, which is responsible for the mechanism of formation of crystallization nuclei and the formation of the phase composition of alloys. It is assumed that a substantial supersaturation of the solid solution with nickel atoms is associated with the introduction of Al3Ni-type clusters into the aluminum matrix of the Al-3Ni-3Fe alloy. This concept is confirmed by the presence of two exothermic peaks on the DSC curves in the region before the crystallization of the alloy and explains the abnormally high value of Young’s modulus and the high yield stress of the alloy.
Keywords: Crystallization kinetics; Cluster structure of the melt; Thermographic analysis; Young’s modulus
Alloys of the Al-Fe-Ni system are widely used in engineering due to their good fluidity, corrosion resistance, heat resistance, and their electrophysical properties [1,2], and also as magnetic materials and in shape-memory devices [3-6]. In this regard, this system of alloys is fairly well studied both scientifically and technologically. The authors of work  studied the effect of the cooling rate on the microstructure and hardness of the Al-1.0Fe-1.0Ni alloy during directed crystallization. They established the relationship between the cooling rate, the formation of the microstructure, hardness and the distance between the eutectic phase. Powder metallurgy methods and the process of rapid solidification were also used to form a specific morphology of the bulk eutectic phase [8,9].
Modern ideas about the structure of metal melts are based on cluster models, such as atomic groups with a certain short-range order (spatial ordering), confirmed by numerous studies using X-ray, electron and neutron analysis, NMR, electrical resistance, internal friction/ viscosity, etc. [10-13]. The cluster structure of the liquid state affects the nucleation of crystals and is manifested in the features of the kinetics of crystallization and, as a result, determines the final structure, phase composition, and physic-mechanical properties of metal alloys. In this regard, structural transformations in metal melts and cluster models in liquid physics in recent years have been the subject of intensive research in related areas of metallurgy, physical chemistry, metal physics, and physical materials science. Thus, works [12,13] were devoted to the study of the local atomic ordering of binary Al-Fe and Al-Ni melts. However, the influence of the cluster structure of the melt of the ternary system on the crystallization kinetics, phase composition, and properties has not been studied sufficiently. Therefore, the aim of this work is a comparative analysis of the crystallization features of Al-3Fe and Al- 3Ni binary systems and Al-3Fe-3Ni and Al-3Ni-3Fe alloys, as well as the formation of their microstructure and mechanical properties caused by the order of introduction of alloying elements in the ternary system.
Al-3Fe and Al-3Ni alloys and Al-3Fe-3Ni and Al-3Ni-3Fe, AK-7 alloys with 4 wt.% Fe were smelted in a smelter with resistive heating in argon medium from 99.99% pure Al. The melt temperature was controlled and maintained with an accuracy of ±1ºС. The temperature of the superheat and the spill of the melt was 850 °C. To completely dissolve the alloying elements, the melt was intensively stirred for 15 minutes after each x170 mm.
The temperatures of the various crystallization stages were fixed using a chromel - alumel thermocouple introduced into the melt to a depth of ~3mm through the crystallizer body. The characteristics of the thermosensitive element provide very low inertia of the thermocouple when measuring the temperature of the medium. The te introduction of impurities. The melt was poured into a massive copper mold with dimensions of 70x60mperature value was recorded using a hardware-software computerized complex in real-time, allowing us to record 500 values per 1 sec. In order to exclude the thermal noise of the thermocouple, the initial curve (an array of 30,000 points) was pre-processed (smoothed) by the method of averaging using the graphic pack “Origin 7.5”.
X-ray diffraction experiments were performed on a DRONUM1 diffractometer in monochromatic Cu-Kα radiation. Graphite monocrystal was used as a monochromator. Diffractograms were recorded by the step scanning method in the 10-120° range of 2Θ angles. The scanning step was 0.05° with an exposure time of 3-9sec. Data processing was carried out using the Powder Cell 2.4 program for the full-profile analysis of x-ray spectra from a mixture of polycrystalline phase components. Studies of melting and crystallization processes of prototypes were carried out using a STA 449F1 synchronous thermal analyzer from NETZSCH, Germany at a heating and cooling rate of 20 °C/min. Mechanical tensile tests were carried out on a 1246P-2/2300 machine of the NIKIMP design using cylindrical samples with a diameter of 3mm and a working part length of l0 ≈18.5 mm at a strain rate of 10-3 s-1 in accordance with DSTU EN 10002-1: 2006 at room temperature. The engineering strain was fixed with a strain gauge directly from the working part of the sample. Vickers hardness was measured on a hardness tester HPO-250 under 5kg load.
A comparative analysis of the sequence of phase transformations, the establishment of temperature and time intervals, as well as the features of crystallization of eutectic alloys, was carried out by comparing the results of direct thermal analysis of the kinetics of crystallization. This approach turned out to be effective and made it possible to establish a number of patterns of crystallization of the Mg-Al-Ca-Ti alloy [14,15] under the influence of electrohydropulse and magnetoimpulse treatment of the melt during AK7 crystallization . Figure 1 & 2 show thermograms of crystallization of the Al-3Fe alloy obtained under identical cooling conditions. The melt cooling rate before crystallization began was 50 °C/s. For a more accurate graphical determination of time and temperature intervals, as well as characteristic points, we used the first time derivative of temperature in coordinates dT/dt-T (Figure 3 & 4). DSC crystallization curves of Al-3Fe-3Ni and Al-3Ni- 3Fe alloys are shown in Figure 5. Measured mechanical properties and Vickers hardness of the alloys are given in the Table 1. The microstructure of the alloys is shown in Figure 6.
Figure 1: Cooling curves for Al-3Fe (1) -and Al-3Ni (2) melts.
Figure 2: Cooling curves for Al-3Fe-3Ni (1) and Al- 3Ni-3Fe (2) melts.
Figure 3: Cooling rate curves for Al-3Fe (1) and Al- 3Ni (2) melts.
Figure 4: Cooling rate curves for Al-3Fe-3Ni (1) and Al-3Ni-3Fe (2) melts.
Figure 5: DSC crystallization curves for Al-3Fe-3Ni (1) and Al-3Ni-3Fe (2) alloys.
Figure 6: Microstructure of Al-3Ni-3Fe (a) and Al-3Fe-3Ni (b) alloys.
Table 1: Properties of Al-3Fe-3Ni and Al-3Ni-3Fe alloys
State diagrams and phase equilibria of binary and ternary aluminum systems with iron and nickel have been studied in a large number of works [for example monograph ], while the structure of liquid melts from the point of view of local atomic ordering and its effect on the crystallization process, microstructure formation and properties of alloys are still insufficiently studied even for binary systems.
In works [12,13], the atomic structure of liquid Fe-Al alloys was studied by X-ray diffraction and viscosity measurements. It was shown that all the studied melts of the Fe-Al system are microinhomogeneous and contain atomic micro formations (clusters), which differ in composition and atomic packing. There are four types of clusters, two of which contain atoms of the same kind (Fe or Al); the composition of two other types of clusters is similar to ordering in stoichiometric solid phases Fe2Al5 and Fe3Al. Changes in concentrations of components in Fe-Al alloys lead to a change in the volume fraction of each type of cluster, while the atomic composition and arrangement of atoms inside the clusters remain constant.
The studies of structure in liquid alloys of Al-Ni system were carried in works [18-24]. The authors note a short-range ordering with the formation of Al-Ni clusters, the size, and distance between atoms depends on the temperature and concentration of nickel in the melt. The analysis of the dependence of viscosity on Ni concentration at a temperature of 800 °C shows that Al3Ni-type clusters are formed in the region above 1.5 at.% .
In accordance with the data of work , the melt overheating temperature was chosen at 850 °C, which at a nickel concentration of 3 wt.% is sufficient for the formation of Al3Ni and Fe3Al clusters. As seen from Figure 3, crystallization of the Al-3Fe alloy has a pronounced two-stage character and begins at 630 °C, which is 42 °C earlier than the beginning of crystallization of the Al-3Ni alloy. Thus the crystallization interval of the first alloy (155 °C) is 20 °C less, and the solidification process takes place with a higher average speed (60 °C and 50 °C, respectively). From this, it can be concluded that the Fe and Al atoms interact more strongly, which at a given melt temperature indicates an energetically less favorable formation of Al3Ni-type clusters, their transformation (growth) into crystallization nuclei, and a significant supercooling of the melt is required for this process to occur. Unlike binary systems, the curves of the cooling rate of the melts of ternary systems (Figure 4) show distinct peaks in the range of 620-650 °C, which correspond to the formation and growth of eutectic crystallization nuclei. From a comparison of Figure 3, curve 1 and Figure 4 it can be seen that the temperature at which crystallization of ternary alloys begins is weakly dependent on the order of introduction of alloying elements and is closer to the temperature at which crystallization of the Al- 3Fe alloy begins. At the same time, the crystallization of the Al- 3Fe-3Ni alloy occurs in the range of 123 °C and its character is similar to the crystallization of the binary Al-3Fe system, while the crystallization of the Al-3Ni-3Fe alloy corresponds to a wider range of 220 °C. In this case, the average crystallization rate practically does not differ and amounts to 55 °C/s. From this, we can conclude that the kinetics of crystallization of the ternary system, at least at the initial stage, is due to the formation of nuclei based on Fe3Al clusters, which, according to , can dissolve up to 3-4 wt.% Ni, while Al3Ni-type clusters dissolve less than 1 wt.% Ni. Therefore, when Fe is introduced first, Fe3Al type clusters are formed, which are able to completely dissolve nickel and transform into eutectic crystallization nuclei of the Al9(Ni,Fe)2 type. This also explains the presence of the third low-temperature stage of crystallization of the Al-3Ni-3Fe alloy (with the introduction of the Ni first) in the range of 400-490 °C, when additional temperature reduction and additional time are necessary for the conversion of Al3Ni-type clusters to crystallization nuclei. Moreover, in the temperature range of the previous eutectic crystallization on the DSC curves of the Al-3Ni- 3Fe alloy (Figure 5, curve 2), two exothermic peaks are observed, while only one peak precedes the crystallization of the Al-3Fe-3Ni alloy. Obviously, these thermal effects correspond to the formation of crystallization nuclei in the melt by the cluster mechanism, which confirms the outlined ideas. These features of the crystallization kinetics of ternary systems are manifested in the formation of the microstructure (Figure 6) and phase composition of the alloy. A narrower crystallization interval of the first alloy promoted the formation of more dispersed particles of this phase (Figure 6). According to X-ray diffractometry data, the alloy contains the Al9Fe1.7Ni0.3 phase, with the volume fraction of the phase in the Al- 3Fe-3Ni alloy being 10.5%, whereas when nickel is introduced first it is significantly less - 6.73%. The difference in phase composition caused a different concentration of alloying elements in the solid solution. A local X-ray spectral analysis showed that when nickel is introduced first, its concentration in the solid solution is 2.7 wt.%, which is higher than when iron is introduced first - 1.9 wt.%. The concentration of iron atoms in the alloys differs insignificantly 1.1- 1.2 wt.%. A high nickel concentration may be due to the fact that part of the Al3Ni and, to a lesser extent, Fe3Al type clusters are not involved in the formation of new phase nuclei, but are introduced into the solid solution under conditions of nonequilibrium crystallization. This assumption is confirmed by the fact that the lattice parameter of aluminum is 4.049 Å and is close to its value for pure metal 4.050 Å.
As can be seen from the table, the strength, plasticity and hardness of the alloys differ insignificantly, however, the yield strength and Young’s modulus, physical qualities characterizing the state of the dislocation-impurity system and the nature of the interatomic interaction are significantly higher for the Al-3Ni-3Fe alloy. Moreover, DSC analysis showed that upon repeated slow crystallization of the Al-3Ni-3Fe alloy superheated to 1000 °C in the temperature range of the preceding eutectic crystallization, two peaks are observed on the curve, which correspond to the formation of ternary phase nuclei by the cluster mechanism described above. It is known  that even small nickel additives significantly impair the amorphization ability of aluminum-based alloys with iron, which is manifested in the presence of Al-Ni clusters in amorphous materials, which subsequently transform into nuclei of the metastable decagonal quasicrystalline phase . Accordingly, we can assume that the abnormally high values of Young’s modulus are explained either by the presence of a nanoscale triple metastable decagonal quasicrystalline phase, which is formed as a result of diffusion flows initiated by elastic distortions of the lattice under loading, or by the formation of nanoscale cluster compounds with a short-range order similar to ordering of the intermetallic Al9(Ni,Fe)2 phase. Obviously, more research is needed to determine the preferred hardening mechanism of this alloy.
A comparative analysis of crystallization thermograms of binary Al-3Fe and Al-3Ni and ternary Al-3Fe-3Ni and Al-3Ni-3Fe alloys from the standpoint of the cluster model of the structure of liquid metal melts made it possible to explain the specific features of the crystallization kinetics of these objects under conditions of rapid cooling. Since the order of introduction of alloying elements does not affect the initial crystallization temperature of the ternary system, and it corresponds to the temperature of the beginning of crystallization of the Al-3Fe alloy, we can conclude that the formation of ternary phase nuclei occurs on the basis of Fe3Al-type clusters. This conclusion confirms the narrow temperature range of crystallization of the Al-3Fe-3Ni alloy.
Iron and nickel belong to metallic impurities that are poorly soluble in aluminum; their concentration in a solid solution of aluminum, depending on its purity, can vary from hundredths to tenths of a percent. At the same time, the concentrations of these elements observed in the solid solution significantly exceed the equilibrium values for binary systems, while the lattice parameter of the aluminum matrix practically corresponds to the value for pure aluminum. Consequently, it can be assumed that there are local nanoscale regions beyond the sensitivity of X-ray diffractometry, in which the concentrations of iron and nickel (especially) atoms exceed the equilibrium one. Since melts of binary systems are prone to the formation of heterogeneous clusters, it is logical to assume that it is these objects that are introduced into the aluminum solid solution in the case of crystallization of the ternary system. This conclusion is confirmed by DSC analysis of crystallization of the Al-3Ni-3Fe alloy, when two exothermic peaks corresponding to the formation of ternary phase nuclei based on two types of clusters are observed in the eutectic pre-crystallization region. This manifests the effect of “genetic heredity” of atomic ordering in clusters in the melt and clusters in solid solution. It should be emphasized that on the DSC crystallization curves of the Al-3Fe-3Ni alloy, we observe only one exothermic peak corresponding to the formation of ternary phase nuclei, based on clusters that probably contain atoms of all three elements. The ideas presented in the article about the specific features of the crystallization kinetics explain not only the differences in the phase composition of the alloys (volume fraction of the Al9Fe1.7Ni0.3 phase), but also the abnormally high Young’s modulus of the Al-3Ni-3Fe alloy.
© 2020 Maksymchuk IM. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.