Diabetes mellitus is a worldwide disease that requires special and continuous medical care. Many classes
of oral hypoglycemic drugs are currently used; however, the treatment strategy depends on the nature of
diabetes type, pharmacological properties of the used drugs in addition to the clinical characteristics of
the patient. As such, in this literature review, we will shed the light on the pharmacology and analytical
chemistry profile of certain oral hypoglycemic drugs specifically Dapagliflozin, Empagliflozin and
Saxagliptin that got attention in the last decade. Mode of action and most of up-to-date reported methods
that have been developed for determination of these important anti-diabetic drugs in their pure form,
combined form with other drugs, combined form with degradation products, and in biological samples
are mentioned in detail.
Diabetes mellitus is a lifelong condition requiring continuous medical care. Chronic
long-term hyperglycemia associated with diabetes that causes serious complications lead
to either drug monitoring in the line of treatment single or combined dosage form. Type 2
Diabetes Mellitus (T2DM) is a worldwide problem affecting approximately 8% of the adult
population, with predictions of more than 400 million cases by 2030 [1]. The prevalence of
T2DM implies an urgent need for new treatments and preventative strategies. The disease
results from progressive β-cell dysfunction in the presence of chronic insulin resistance,
leading to a progressive decline in plasma glucose homeostasis, increased glucagon secretion,
gluconeogenesis, and renal glucose reabsorption and reduced incretin response. Treatments
recommended by the American diabetes association and the European association for the
study of diabetes include drugs affecting all of the above processes [2]. Monotherapy with
an oral medication should be started concomitantly with intensive lifestyle management.
When glycemic control is no longer maintained with a single drug, the addition of a second or
third oral hypoglycemic drugs usually more effective than switching to another single drug.
Hypoglycemic drugs comprise a chemically and pharmacologically heterogeneous group of
drugs. There are different classes of oral hypoglycemic drugs and their selection depends on
the nature of diabetes, pharmacological properties of the compounds such as efficacy, safety
profile and the clinical characteristics of the patient (stage of disease, age and bodyweight)
[3]. These drugs, which exhibit different modes of action may be used as a monotherapy or in
various combinations..
Gliflozins
Gliflozins are the newest class of approved oral hypoglycemic agents that specifically
inhibit sodium glucose co-transporter 2 function in the kidney, thus preventing renal glucose
reabsorption and increasing glycosuria in diabetic individuals while
reducing hyperglycemia with a minimal risk of hypoglycemia. They
reduce glycated hemoglobin and exert favorable effects beyond
glucose control with consistent body weight, blood pressure, and
serum uric acid reductions. The main drugs from this group are
Dapagliflozin (DGF) and empagliflozin (EGF) [4-8].
Gliptins
Gliptins represent a novel class of agents that improve beta
cell health and suppress glucagon, resulting in improved postprandial
and fasting hyperglycemia. They function by augmenting
the incretin system (GLP-1 and GIP) preventing their metabolism
by Dipeptidyl Peptidase-4 (DPP-4). Not only are they efficacious but
also safe (weight neutral) and do not cause significant hypoglycemia,
making it a unique class of drugs. The main drug from this group is
Saxagliptin (SXG) [9].
Mechanism of sodium glucose co-transporter 2
Inhibitors
SGLT2 is a protein in humans that facilitates glucose
reabsorption in the kidney. SGLT2 inhibitors block the reabsorption
of glucose in the kidney, increase glucose excretion, and lower
blood glucose levels. SGLT2 is a low-affinity, high capacity glucose
transporter located in the proximal tubule in the kidneys. It is
responsible for 90% of glucose reabsorption. Inhibition of SGLT2
leads to decrease in blood glucose due to the increase in renal
glucose excretion. The mechanism of action of this new class of drugs
also offers further glucose control by allowing increased insulin
sensitivity and uptake of glucose in the muscle cells, decreased
gluconeogenesis and improved first phase insulin release from the
beta cells. Drugs in the SGLT2 inhibitors class include DGF and EGF,
these drugs in this class approved by the FDA for the treatment
of type 2 diabetes. The usage of studied drugs as tinny amount
and very diluted in biological matrix to analyze studied drugs in
low levels to be applied in their assay in biological samples and
give challenge to find suitable method for analysis of these drugs.
Therefore, a new simple and sensitive spectroscopic method was
required to achieve the aim of this study. Moreover, it is well-known
that spectrofluorimetric methods are much more sensitive than
spectrophotometric methods [10]. Furthermore, studied drugs
analysis in the required low level in plasma samples by measuring
the native fluorescence of each DGF and EGF and needed the use
of a fluorogenic derivatizing reagent to enhance the sensitivity of
the analysis by producing a highly sensitive fluorophore. Therefore,
benzofurazan derivative was used in this study for the first time
to develop a new validated and sensitive spectrofluorimetric
analytical method for studied drug analysis in all sample matrices
either pure or biological. A way to speed up the validation process
consists of the use of experimental design, which can be very useful
and advantageous for both the evaluation and the optimization of
some performance parameters. Experimental design techniques
are powerful tools for the exploration of multivariate systems [11-
13]. Statistical design is a way of choosing experiments; efficiently
and systematically to give reliable and coherent information. From
a statistical standpoint, design means construction of experiments
so that the analysis of results yields the maximum amount of
information that can be extracted from the experiments. More
specifically, experimental design helps the researcher to verify if
changes in factor values produce a statistically significant variation
of the observed response, and this approach can be used each
time it is necessary to have this type of information. Typically,
experimental design techniques are used to understand the effect
of several variables on a system by a well-defined mathematical
model. The strategy is most effective if statistical design is used
in most or all stages of development and not only for screening
or optimizing the process. A systematic use of statistical design in
developing a method ensures traceability, supports validation, and
makes the subsequent confirmatory validation much easier and
more certain. In fact, it is difficult to completely separate method
optimization from validation since these two areas are linked, and
sometimes a compromise has to be found [14]. There is no reported
voltammetry study for DGF analysis in the literature. DGF acts as
electroactive compound and it is easily oxidized. The development
of electrochemical-based sensors is considered important.
Electrochemical sensors have the reputation of being small,
quick, cheap, and easy to use for analytical applications, but their
designing to be sensitive and selective for analyte of interest is a
challenge. The rapid nature of electrochemistry makes it appealing
for use in medical applications where quick tests are necessary
for medical diagnostics, to ensure drug quality, and to understand
dynamics of molecular changes during diseases. Therefore, polymer
films modified electrodes received a great attention recently due
to their wide applications in the fields of chemical sensors and
biosensors [15-19]. Such modified electrodes can significantly
improve the electrocatalytic properties of substrates, decrease the
over potential, increase the reaction rate and improve the stability
and reproducibility of the electrode response in the area of electro
analysis [20-29]. The incorporation of metallic Nanoparticles (NPs)
into conductive polymers is of great interest because of their strong
electronic interactions between NPs and the polymer matrices.
It has been reported that the electrocatalytic properties and
conductivities of NPs could be enhanced by the conductive polymeric
matrices [19]. Previously, Poly 1,5‑Diaminonaphthalene (PDAN)
was prepared in aqueous and nonaqueous media at Glassy Carbon
(GC) electrode [20-22]. The electrodeposition of metal NPs in the
polymer films improves their tolerance towards electrooxidation of
small molecules [30]. Herein, in this perspective, PDAN films were
prepared at the surface of GC electrode, followed by monometallic
Platinum (Pt) or Palladium (Pd) NPs electrodeposition. Suitability
of these new composite NPs modified polymeric GC electrodes
towards the electrocatalytic oxidation of studied drugs have been
studied by electrochemical measurements. On the other hand, The
combination therapy of DGF and SXG was shown to be superior
in lowering blood glucose when compared with either of the
monotherapy regimens [31]. However, this combination therapy
leads to a big challenge in pharmaceutical and biomedical analysis
area. Therefore, it is important to get a valid analytical separation
technique suitable for the analysis of these drugs in presence of
each other. Also, the analysis should be valid in presence of their
degradation products and also in pharmaceutical dosage form. High
Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography (HPTLC) has several
advantages over HPLC in some analysis. As HPTLC, separations
are generally more efficient than HPLC. Also, it takes short time
for analysis. Moreover, it requires few nanoliter injection volumes.
Furthermore, minimal use of solvent and no prior extraction steps
compared to HPLC [32,33].
Chemistry of the investigated oral hypoglycemic drugs
The chemical structures and pharmacokinetic parameters of
the investigated drugs and their chemical names are presented in
Tables 1 & 2.
Table 1:The names, chemical structures and nomenclature of the studied oral hypoglycemic drugs
Table 2:Pharmacokinetic and physicochemical parameters of the studied oral antidiabetic drugs.
Analytical methods for the determination of certain
antidiabetic drugs
Pharmaceutical analysis has become one of the most important
stages in the therapeutic process. Drug analysis includes analytical
investigations of bulk drug materials, intermediate products, drug
formulations, impurities and degradation products. Analytical
techniques play a significant role in understanding the chemical
stability of the drug, in evaluating the toxicity of some impurities
and in assessing the content of drug in formulations. Also, they
are fundamental tools in pharmacokinetic studies where the
analysis of a drug and its metabolites in biological fluids must be
performed. This review presents analytical procedures such as
spectrophotometric (UV/VIS) methods, HPLC and HPTLC methods.
It is based on a review of the literature from (2009-2020). The
studied drugs (DGF, EGF and SXG) have not an official method in
any pharmacopeia. The reported method included;
i. Spectroscopic methods
ii. Spectrophotometric methods
iii. Ultraviolet and visible spectrophotometric methods:
In literature survey, either spectrophotometric methods have
been reported for determination of the studied drugs in pure forms
or in their pharmaceutical preparations. These reported methods
are summarized in Table 3; [34-48].
Table 3:Spectrophotometric (UV/VIS) methods for the analysis of DGF, EGF and SXG in bulk materials and formulations.
Spectrofluorimetric methods
The reported spectrofluorimetric methods for the investigated
drugs as the following
Spectrofluorimetric methods of SAX and vildagliptin in bulk and
pharmaceutical preparations using NBD-Cl fluorogenic reagent at
λex of 468 and 465nm for SAX and VDG, respectively. Fluorescence
intensity at λem of 542 and 540nm for SAX and VDG, respectively
[49]. A simple and highly sensitive spectrofluorimetric method
was developed and validated for the determination of sitagliptin
phosphate and SAX. The proposed method is based on Hantzsch
reaction of both drugs. Fluorescent products in presence of sodium
dodecyl sulfate micellar system as additive to enhance the obtained
fluorescence at 483nm after excitation at 419nm for both drugs
[50].
High Performance Thin-Layer Chromatography (HPTLC)
A high-performance thin-layer chromatographic method was
developed and validated for simultaneous determination of EGF
and Linagliptin. The proposed method was applied successfully to
the pharmaceutical analysis using precoated silica plates coated
with 0.2mm layers of silica gel 60 F254 and methanol: toluene:
ethyl acetate (2:4:4, v/v/v) was selected as mobile phase [51].
Stability indicating HPTLC-MS method for estimation of EGF in
pharmaceutical dosage form using silica plates coated with 0.2mm
layers of silica gel 60 F254 and toluene : methanol (7:3, v/v)
was selected as mobile phase [52]. HPTLC was developed for the
quantitative analysis of SXG in active pharmaceutical ingredients
(APIs) and pharmaceutical dosage forms. The method was achieved
using silica gel aluminum plate 60 F254 (10×10cm) as stationary
phase and methanol: chloroform (6:4, v/v) as mobile phase [53].
HPTLC method for the simultaneous determination of metformin,
SXG and DGF in pharmaceuticals. Separation was performed using
aluminum HPTLC sheets coated with silica gel 60 F254 with a mobile
phase consisting of a mixture of acetonitrile: 1% w/v ammonium
acetate in methanol (9:1,v/v), scanning was performed at 210nm
[54]. HPTLC analytical method for simultaneous estimation of DGF
and SXG in synthetic mixture using silica gel aluminum plate 60
F254(10×10cm)as stationary phase and chloroform: ethyl acetate:
methanol: ammonia (6:2:2:2 drops) as mobile phase [55]. HPTLC
method was developed for the determination of either linagliptin,
SXG or vildagliptin in their binary mixtures with metformin in
pharmaceutical preparations. Separation was carried out on Merck
HPTLC aluminum sheets of silica gel 60 F254 using methanol: 0.5%
w/v aqueous ammonium sulfate (8:2,v/v) as mobile phase [56].
High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)
Various HPLC methods had been reported for the determination
of the studied drugs either alone or in combination with others
active ingredients in dosage forms or in biological fluids. Table 4;
[57-85]: summarized the most recent applications of this technique.
Capillary electrophoresis methods
A Capillary Electrophoretic method coupled to a Diode
Array Detector (CE-DAD) was developed and validated for the
simultaneous determination of metformin hydrochloride, SAX
and DGF. The proposed method was used for the determination
of these drugs in combinations namely, SXG/metformin, DGF/
metformin and SXG/DGF. CE separation was performed on a fused
silica capillary with background electrolyte consisting of 30mM
phosphate buffer (pH 6.0). The compounds were detected at 203nm
for SXG/DGF and 250nm for metformin. The method was linear in
the concentration ranges of 10-200, 1.25-50 and 7.5-100μg/ml for
SAX, DGF and metformin, respectively [86].
Table 4:HPLC methods for the analysis of DGF, EGF and SXG in bulk materials and formulations.
Electrochemical method
The literature is devoid of any electrochemical methods for the
quantitation of the studied drugs. The first, sensitive and accurate
potentiometric sensor for the selective determination of SXG in the
presence of either its active metabolite 5‑hydroxy SXG, other coadministered
or structurally related drugs [87].
This literature review represents the mode of action in addition
to an up-to-date survey about all reported methods that have been
developed for determination of Dapagliflozin, Empagliflozin and
Saxagliptin in their pure form, combined form with other drugs,
combined form with degradation products, and in biological
samples such as liquid chromatography, spectrophotometry,
spectroflourimetry, electrochemistry, etc.
Pournaghi-Azar MH, Habibi B (2007) Electrocatalytic oxidation of methanol on poly (phenylenediamines) film palladized aluminum electrodes, modified by Pt micro-particles: comparison of permselectivity of the films for methanol. Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry, p-10.
Mante GV, Gupta KR, Hemke AT (2017) Estimation of Dapagliflozin from its tablet formulation by UV-Spectrophotometry. Pharm Methods 8(2): 102-107.
Karuna PC, China EM, Rao MB (2015) Unique UV spectrophotometric method for reckoning of dapagliflozin in bulk and pharmaceutical dosage forms. J Chem Pharm Res 7(9): 45-49.
Padmaja N, Babu MS, Veerabhadram G (2016) Development and validation of UV spectrophotometric method for simultaneous estimation of smpagliflozin and metformin hydrochloride in bulk drugs and combined dosage forms. Der Pharmacia Lettre 8(13): 207-213.
Jyothirmai N, Nagaraju B, Anil Kumar M (2016) Novel uv and visible spectrophotometric methods for the analysis of empagliflozin a type 2 diabetic drug in bulk and pharmaceutical formulations. Journal De Afrikana 3(1): 177-187.
Patil SD, Chaure SK, Kshirsagar S (2017) Development and validation of UV spectrophotometric method for Simultaneous estimation of Empagliflozin and Metformin hydrochloride in bulk drugs. AJPAna 7(2): 117-123.
Shaker L (2016) Development of Economic UV Spectrophotometric method for determination of linagliptin in its tertiary mixture with empagliflozin and metformin: comparision to economic pharmaceutical analysis literature. Scholars Research Library 8(13): 267-269.
Narendra N, Govinda J (2012) Development and validation of uv-vis spectroscopy method for simultaneous estimation of saxagliptin hydrochloride and metformin hydrochloride in active pharmaceutical ingredient. J Pharm Educ Res 3(2): 19-23.
Debata J, Kumar S, Jha SK, Khan A (2017) A new RP-HPLC method development and validation of dapagliflozin in bulk and tablet dosage form. Int J Drug Dev & Res 9(2): 48-51.
Khalil GA, Salama I, Gomaa MS, Helal MA (2018) Validated RP-HPLC method for simultaneous determination of canagliflozin, dapagliflozin, empagliflozin and metformin. IJPCBS 8(1): 1-13.
Bhagavanji N (2012) Development and validation of stability indicating LC method for the simultaneous estimation of metformin and saxagliptin in combined dosage form. VSRD International Journal of Technical & Non-Technical Research 3(11): 1-19.
Caglar S, Ali RA (2014) A validated high performance liquid chromatography method for the determination of saxagliptin and metformin in bulk, a stability indicating study. J Anal Bioanal Techs 12: 2.
Daswadkar SC, Roy MA, Walode SG, Mahendra KC (2016) Quality by design approach for the development and validation of saxagliptin by RP-HPLC with application to formulated forms. Int J Pharm Sci 7(4): 1670-1677.
Godasu S, Sreenivas S (2017) A new validated RP-HPLC method for the determination of Metformin HCL and Empagliflozin in its bulk and pharmaceutical dosage forms. IJPSR 8(5): 2223-2232.
Padmaja N, Veerabhadram G (2017) A novel stability indicating rp-uplc-dad method for determination of metformin and empagliflozin in bulk and tablet dosage form. Oriental Journal of Chemistry 33(4): 1949-1958.
Jaiswal SH, Katariya M, Katariya V, Karva G, Koshe K (2017) Validated stability indicating hplc method for determination of process related impurities in empagliflozin drug substances. World Journal of Pharmaceutical Research 6: 8741.
Professor, Chief Doctor, Director of Department of Pediatric Surgery, Associate Director of Department of Surgery, Doctoral Supervisor Tongji hospital, Tongji medical college, Huazhong University of Science and Technology
Senior Research Engineer and Professor, Center for Refining and Petrochemicals, Research Institute, King Fahd University of Petroleum and Minerals (KFUPM), Dhahran, Saudi Arabia
Interim Dean, College of Education and Health Sciences, Director of Biomechanics Laboratory, Sport Science Innovation Program, Bridgewater State University