William A Hubbard*, Michael J Elliot and Francis J Veale
Department of Marine Science Safety and Environmental Protection, Massachusetts Maritime Academy, Buzzards Bay, USA
*Corresponding author: William A Hubbard, Department of Marine Science Safety and Environmental Protection, Massachusetts Maritime Academy, Buzzards Bay, USA
Submission: July 02, 2020;Published: uly 10, 2020
ISSN 2578-031X Volume3 Issue4
The black sea bass Centropristis striata population of the Northwest Atlantic has been expanding over the past decade throughout its northern extent in Massachusetts waters. As abundance has increased in the coastal waters of Massachusetts, valuable commercial and recreational fisheries have developed. Relatively little is known about the habitat requirements for black sea bass at different life stages in Massachusetts waters. Identification and conservation of critical habitats is an essential component of sustainable fisheries management. In this study we conducted underwater video transects in Buzzards Bay, MA to better understand the habitats used by young-of-the-year black sea bass. We specifically focused on a comparison between Crepidula fornicata shell reefs and sandy/sponge habitats. Our results suggest that juvenile, young-of-the-year black sea bass are present in statistically significant higher densities on the Crepidula fornicata shell reefs than in the sandy bottom habitat. This sampling identified an average of eight times more fish on the shell reef habitat, implicating the shell reefs as a potential nursery habitat in Massachusetts waters. Crepidula reefs should be considered for designation as Special, Sensitive or Unique resource in the Massachusetts Ocean Management Plan.
Keywords: Massachusetts; Black sea; Coastal water; Finfish species; Cape cod
Climate mediated shifts in the ranges and distribution of fish populations pose important challenges for management and conservation. In the Northwest Atlantic, shifting species distributions have been documented for a suite of recreationally, commercially, and ecologically important finfish species . As species expand into areas previously unoccupied, it is imperative to understand how they are using habitats in these new areas and which habitats may require further protection to ensure sustainability and productivity of fish populations throughout their contemporary range.
Black sea bass Centropristis striata are distributed from Cape Cod, Massachusetts south to the Gulf of Mexico. Two distinct genetic stocks have been identified, delineating this population into a Northern and Southern stock, with Cape Hatteras, North Carolina serving as the breakpoint between the two [2,3]. Over the past few decades, the Northern black sea bass stock has undergone a rapid northward shift in its center of distribution [4,5]. Black sea bass is presently one of the largest recreational fisheries in the state of Massachusetts, with recreational anglers harvesting an estimated 743,617lb in 2017. Understanding how this burgeoning population is using different habitats at different life stages, in the coastal waters of Massachusetts, is imperative for conservation and sustainable management. In this paper, we focus on the habitat use of juvenile black sea bass in the northern extent of their range, Buzzards Bay, Massachusetts.
Like many of the seasonally migratory species that inhabit the coastal waters of the northeastern United States, black sea bass occupy the inshore waters for the spring and summer months, and then migrate to deeper warmer waters to overwinter [5,6]. Spawning activity occurs annually from May through July, with the peak in June [7,8]. Once juveniles settle out of the pelagic stage and become demersal, cover and prey availability become limiting factors to their success . Young-of-the-year (YOY; age 0) utilize the shallow, nearshore habitats until their first offshore migration in the fall of the same year they were hatched. Structured habitats are favored over open sandy or muddy bottom . In addition, YOY exhibit site fidelity and territorial behaviors during their juvenile phase [11,12].
Juvenile black sea bass are known to forage on rocky and shell substrates (Figure 1); dominant prey for juveniles include crustaceans and small fish . Recent benthic studies in Buzzards Bay, Massachusetts have identified associations between juvenile black sea bass and several large Crepidula fornicata (common slipper shell; hereafter, crepidula) shell reefs extending to over forty hectares (approximately one hundred acres) each . These shell reefs may be important forage and shelter areas that allow many valuable recreational finfish species to proliferate in Massachusetts. In Europe, crepidula are considered invasive, imported with oysters from North America, and have been expanding with warming sea temperatures . Crepidula are native to Massachusetts waters, however, there is evidence that their abundance and distribution has increased in recent decades . Despite the prevalence of black sea bass in Massachusetts waters, relatively little is known about their habitat use at different life stages.
Figure 1: Still screen shot from video transect showing juvenile black sea bass on a Crepidula fornicata shell reef in Buzzards Bay, MA.
In this study, we sought to better understand YOY black sea bass occupancy of different habitats to identify important nursery habitats , defined nursery habitats as those that contribute a greater than average number of individuals to the adult population on a per-unit-area basis as compared to other juvenile habitats. We used underwater video transects to quantify black sea bass YOY density in two different habitat types, structured (Crepidula reef) and non-structured (sandy bottom). Understanding how different habitats are contributing to recruitment to the adult population is important for the protection of important habitats, but also to improve our ability to predict future productivity and recruitment based on availability of optimal habitat.
On 23 and 24 of August 2016, we conducted two sampling events using high definition (Sea viewer 6000) underwater video cameras to produce video recordings (Sea viewer HDMI H.264 Recorder) of a Crepidula reef (C-reef) and a sandy habitat with the massive form morphology of boring sponge Cliona celata. In upper Buzzards Bay the dominant substrates are sand, sand with sponge, shell reefs, macro algae beds and submerged aquatic vegetation. The videos were recorded from a surface deployed camera in profile view and were post-processed to produce screen shot stills used to document and quantify juvenile black sea bass densities. The two sampling stations were located 2.5 kilometers apart, in upper (eastern) Buzzards Bay, at the end of Hog Island channel - just outside Stony Dike (Figure 2). The C-reef video was in the general vicinity of 41ᵒ40’28.82”N/ 70ᵒ40’20.35”W, while the sand/sponge video was in the general vicinity of 41ᵒ40’56.93”N/ -70ᵒ42’3.26”W. Video transects were completed at the two sampling locations between depths of five and six meters. We obtained still screen shots from the video transect data (Figure 3). All screen shots were reviewed in full screen, in eight zoom quadrants and then with enhanced contrast/color scaling. Images with at least 90% of the field-of-view suitable for examination were retained for the analysis. Screen shots that were out of focus, taken in water too turbid for examination, or were generally of poor quality were excluded.
Figure 2: Map showing the location of the video transects for each habitat type in Buzzards Bay, MA.
Figure 3: Sand/sponge (A) and C-reef shell (B) habitat screen shots from Buzzards Bay video transects.
Thirty-three screen shots from the C-reef and 61 from the sand/sponge habitat were examined in detail, and numbers of Young-of-the-Year (YOY) black sea bass were recorded for each screen shot. The mean fish density from the video transect observations was 6.30 fish/m2 (Sd=4.16) in the C-reef habitat and 0.71 fish/m2 (Sd=0.82) in the sand/sponge habitat. The lack of overlap between the distributions of bootstrapped mean fish density estimates, by habitat, provides strong evidence of a significant difference in fish density between the two habitats (Figure 4). In addition, there were no bootstrap t-values that were greater than or equal to the Student’s t-statistic (t=7.65); further supporting a rejection of the null hypothesis that fish density in the two habitat types is equal (p≈0). The C-reef habitat supported eight times the density of fish observed in the sandy bottom habitat in our study area.
Figure 4: Distribution of bootstrapped mean fish density estimates (fish/m2), by habitat type.
The C-reef slipper shell residents produce a nutrient rich waste that settles in among the stacked shell “curls”. This rich substrate is the result of the water filtration provided by Crepidula fornicata, a unique organism as it is a filter feeding gastropod. Field and laboratory observations indicate the filtration and conversion to a fine organic matter is prolific. Numerous crabs and amphipods are associated with the benthic community of this shell habitat . The small surficial polychaete Polygordius apendiculata can also be a significant forage component of some C-reef habitat. Polygordius has reached densities of over 10,000 organisms per square meter (up to 11700/m2) on some reefs sampled for benthic community composition ; (Figure 5). Other small polychaetes, gastropods and amphipods colonize the interstitial shell spaces providing a diverse symbiotic community. This diverse benthic community provides a significant forage base for juvenile black sea bass and other species . Our results suggest that C-reef habitat could be important nursery habitat for YOY juvenile black sea bass, contributing far greater numbers per-unit-area than the sandy/sponge habitats.  have proposed that it is not just the per-unit-area contributions that should define nursery habitats, but the overall contributions of habitat.
If we make a broad assumption that the field-of-view of each high definition video frame is one square meter, we can allocate the C-reefs to hosting 6.3 juvenile black sea bass per square meter. This is not an inference that this is the quantifiable carrying capacity relationship of these two habitats, just an indication of black sea bass preference for shell versus sand/sponge habitat. The 2017 report for benthic mapping in Buzzards Bay  identified seven areas of dense C-reef habitat in the upper Bay. One is as large as 53 hectares and several more are over 40 hectares. Therefore, a minimum of 700 acres (2.833km2) were documented in the study area; an area predicted to host over seventeen million (17,847,900) YOY. In 2014, the United States Geologic Survey (USGS) conducted a hydroacoustic survey Buzzards Bay which effectively mapped “Shell Zones” .
Figure 5: Still screen shot from video transect showing the small surficial polychaete Polygordius apendiculata, which is a significant forage component for black sea bass in the C-reef habitat.
Shell Zones are areas of high density crepidula beds, identified by high acoustic backscatter in areas of fine-grained surficial sediments, and verified using digital photographs. The Shell Zones identified cover 14.8 km2, which is 2% of the Buzzards Bay sea floor by area; this area is likely larger but has yet to be verified with photographs of the bottom habitat . Assuming if the density we observed in the C-reef habitat is representative of the larger Bay, we estimate this habitat could support approximately 93,240,000 YOY black sea bass.
Buzzards Bay is a dynamic ecosystem and has fluctuated dramatically through time. The contemporary habitats observed throughout the bay have changed considerably from the habitats in the region 50 years ago. In 1955 a benthic infaunal survey of Buzzards Bay was conducted  and was then repeated in 2011 and 2012 . The comparison between the two time periods showed a shift towards higher nutrient concentrations, warmer temperatures, reduction in species diversity, and a restructuring of the benthic community. One of the marked shifts in benthic species composition was the proliferation of crepidula beds. Crepidula was absent from the 1955 samples but showed up as the dominant species at two locations in 2011/2012. In addition, the presence of cprepidula in the Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries’ inshore trawl survey , a synoptic trawl survey that has sampled the coastal waters of Massachusetts twice per year (May and September) since 1978, has generally increased through time (Figure 6).
Figure 6: Average liters per tow of Crepidula fornicata in the Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries inshore trawl survey, from 1983-2017. The gray line represents a loess curve through the data points with the 95% confidence interval depicted by the light gray shaded area.
Climate change and anthropogenic inputs were suggested as potential drivers contributing to the proliferation of the C-reef habitat in Buzzards Bay . Likewise, warming water temperatures has been suggested as an important driving force in the expansion of the black sea bass population into Massachusetts waters . Black sea bass are a prized game fish so as their distribution has shifted north, important recreational and commercial fisheries have developed in the region. The recreational harvest of adult black sea bass averaged 352,443 fish per year during the decade from 2006 to 2017, state-wide in Massachusetts . Adapting to climate change requires an understanding of how different habitats are used at different life stages for a wide range of species. Our results suggest that C-reef habitats contribute substantially to the adult black sea bass population on a per-unit-area. These results combined with the USGS mapping efforts suggest that C-reef is also a large component of the overall bottom habitat in Buzzards Bay; therefore, supporting the classification as important nursery habitat. The tremendous ecological productivity of the Massachusetts crepidula shell reef habitat should be protected. The reliance of important fishery resources on this benthic structure, such as the black sea bass juvenile phase, warrants evaluation as a Special, Sensitive, or Unique (SSU) resource in the Massachusetts Coastal Zone Ocean Management Plan.
This research was supported by the Massachusetts Environmental Trust (https://www.mass.gov/environmentallicense- plates) Coastal America Foundation (www. CoastalAmericaFoundation.org).
© 2020 William A Hubbard. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.