s Mössbauer and X-Ray Fluorescence Studies of Haltern 70 Amphorae from Roman Hispania Provinces|crimson publishers.com
Crimson Publishers Publish With Us Reprints e-Books Video articles

Full Text

Annals of Chemical Science Research

Mössbauer and X-Ray Fluorescence Studies of Haltern 70 Amphorae from Roman Hispania Provinces

Costa BFO1*, Wagner FE2, Wagner U2 and Silva AJM3

1University of Coimbra, CFisUC, Department of Physics, Portugal

2Physics Department, Technical University of Munich, Germany

3School of Technologies and Management, University of Madeira, Portugal

*Corresponding author: Costa BFO, University of Coimbra, CFisUC, Department of Physics, Portugal

Submission: June 22, 2020Published: August 11, 2020

DOI: 10.31031/ACSR.2020.02.000534

Volume2 Issue2
July, 2020

Abstract

Haltern 70 amphora sherds from Castro do Vieito and from production sites in the Roman provinces Baetica and Lusitania were studied by Mössbauer spectroscopy and XRF. The amphorae were fired under reducing atmosphere and oxidized during cooling down. The firing conditions as well as the Ca content are essential for the colour and the state of iron of the amphorae.

Keywords: Haltern 70 amphorae; Mössbauer spectroscopy; X-ray fluorescence analysis; Firing conditions

Introduction

Halter 70 is the name of a type of amphorae that were produced in Hispania, a region of the Roman Empire during the second half of the first century BC and the first century AD. Morphologically, these amphorae are containers of about 0.90m height and a maximum diameter of about 0.35m. They have an irregular cylindrical body, a band rim, two handles with elliptical section and a pointed base filled with a ball of clay [1,2]. Amphorae were the standard vessels for transportation products like wine, vinegar, garum, oil, and other foodstuff in antiquity, from about 1500 BC to 700 AC. For this reason, the Roman provinces did not only produce agricultural products, but also a vast number of amphorae. In the NW of Iberia Haltern 70 amphorae are well documented, being more than 80% of the total number of amphorae found in archaeological sites [3]. Fifteen years ago, the excavation of the Castro do Vieito (NW of Portugal, Rio Lima estuary), where there was a settlement of Roman troops involved in the supply’s network of the Roman army, provided the most extended collection of Haltern 70 amphorae of all the Roman world [1,4].

The origin of these amphorae is still under discussion, although their production sites are usually assigned to several places in Baetica or Lusitania, both provinces of Hispania. Aiming to find the origin of the Castro do Vieito amphorae, an archaeometric study has been started of Castro do Vieito sherds as well as of sherds from the first century AD from a number of production sites of the Roman provinces Baetica and Lusitania. The Baetica sites are Pinguele, Puerto Real, Lebrija, Arva and Orippo, while the Lusitania sites are Marim, São Lourenço and Olhos [1,5,6].s

Results and Discussion

The Castro do Vieito sherds are reddish brown, no longer than 10cm and all exhibited a slight curvature. The specimens from the kiln sites are large fragments of amphorae like rims, handles and foot ends. They have colors ranging from reddish brown to pale cream. The sherds found in Castro do Vieito are soft and could easily be fractured. The most significant feature in all the samples is the sandy texture, sometimes with big inclusions of silicates. XRF results shown that the presence of Si is about 20-30wt% [5,7]. This confirms that sand was added to the raw clay, probably as a temper [8]. Amphorae sherds from Castro do Vieito are similar, and the same is verified for the amphorae from each of the individual sites, that are also quite similar in each group. From the kiln sites, only three typical cases will be described in the following, namely São Lourenço, Lebrija and Arva. The archaeological codes of the items are used in this paper.

The description of the kiln site specimens is as follows: The São Lourenço 1 sherd is the uniformly colored foot of a brick-red amphora; the Lebrija 2 sherd is a piece of an amphora wall with a thickness of about 11 mm of uniform buff-cream color ; the Arva 11 sherd is part of a handle which is red outside and grey in the core. As mentioned before, the Castro do Vieito sherds are reddish. Table 1 presents element contents of the studied sherds. It is observed that Si is the main component in all the samples. The contents of Fe and Al are of the same order in all cases. The broadest range of concentrations is found for Ca, but there are also large differences in the Mg contents, which tend to be high when the Ca contents are high.

Table 1: XRF data for element contents [7].


Figure 1: 57Fe Mössbauer spectra of indicated sherds. RT spectra are shown on the left, 4.2K spectra on the right.


The Mössbauer spectra of the four samples are shown in Figure 1. The room temperature spectra exhibit a strong Fe3+ doublet with a quadrupole splitting of about 80-85mm/s, a weaker Fe2+ doublet and a magnetic contribution, mainly hematite. There may also be a minor broad magnetic contribution fitted with a Gaussian distribution of hyperfine fields, with a mean hyperfine field of about 40T, and attributed to nano-sized hematite or maghemite particles. The Fe2+ doublet found in some samples is always less than 10%. Firing under a reducing atmosphere would show a much higher fraction. The data obtained from RT spectra are incompatible with a purely oxidizing or a strongly reducing firing. The observations already suggest that the amphorae were fired in a changing atmosphere, perhaps under reducing conditions followed by oxidation during cooling down. This seems to be especially true for the sample São Lourenço 1 and explain the hematite percentage observed in the surface but not the core of Arva 11.

At 4.2K part of the broad magnetic pattern is resolved into hematite. The remaining broad distribution, with a mean hyperfine field between 45 and 50 T, is still from a vitreous phase that forms during reducing firing at or above 800 ºC [5,9]. The ferric doublets always decrease substantially when one cools the samples to 4.2K showing that at room temperature there is superparamagnetic hematite. Comparing the spectra obtained at 4.2K, we can observe that Lebrija sample and the sample taken from the core of Arva 11, which are not red in color, have the largest vitreous phase and smallest content of hematite. As described previously [5,9], a glassy phase is formed in a reducing atmosphere at 800 ºC or more. Iron is dissolved in the amorphous phase as Fe2+. When the atmosphere becomes oxidizing at the end of the firing, the ferrous iron oxidizes. Fe3+ is less soluble in the glassy phase and therefore tends to form hematite. For this to occur, diffusion of the iron in the vitreous phase is required, which occurs the faster the higher the temperature is. When the cooling is too fast, oxidation may take place, but the formation of hematite may not occur because of sluggish diffusion. Lebrija and Arva samples have already less iron than the other samples. Moreover, they have more Ca that is proven to stablish the buff color of the fired amphorae [7]. Studies in which these sherds were refired at different temperatures and in different atmospheres [6] showed that the Ca content is essential for the color and state of Fe in the fired samples. Also, it was observed from those studies that a changing kiln atmosphere contribute to different colors in the inside and surface of the amphorae.

Conclusion

Haltern 70 amphora sherds from Castro do Vieito and from production sites in the Roman provinces of Baetica and Lusitania were studied by Mössbauer spectroscopy and XRF. Amphora sherds from Castro do Vieito are similar, and the same is verified for the amphorae from each of the individual sites, that are also quite similar in each group. Mössbauer spectroscopy revealed that the firing procedure was similar for all amphorae, involving a reducing firing around 800 ºC and oxidation during cooling. The firing conditions as well as the Ca content are essential for the color and the state of iron of the amphorae.

Acknowledgement

CFisUC is supported by national funds from FCT-Foundation for Science and Technology, I.P., within the project UID / 04564/2020.

References

  1. Costa BFO, Pereira G, Silva AJM, Ramos Silva M, Do Carmo SJC (2010) Mössbauer study of Haltern 70 amphora sherds from Castro do Vieito, North of Portugal. J Phys 217: 012060.
  2. Etienne R, Mayet F (2000) Hispanic wine. Three keys to the economy of Roman Hispania, Diffusion E. de Boccard, Paris, France, p. 295.
  3. Naveiro López JL (1996) Ceramic record and exchange in the northwest in roman times. In: Fernandez Ochoa C (Ed.), Los Atlantic finisterres in antiquity. Pre-Roman and Roman times, Electa, Gijon, Spain, pp. 201-204
  4. Silva AJM (2012) Living beyond the river of forgetting. Portrait of the village community of Catro do Vieito at the time of the integration of the NW of the Iberian Peninsula into the Orbis Romanum (Rio Lima estuary, NW of Portugal), British Archaelogical Reports, Archaeopress, Oxford, UK.
  5. Costa BFO, Silva AJM, Ramalho A, Pereira G, Ramos Silva M (2012) X-ray compositional microanalysis and diffraction studies of Haltern 70 amphorae sherds. X-Ray Spectrom 41(2): 69-74
  6. Costa BFO, Silva AJM, Wagner FE, Wagner U (2011) Mössbauer studies of Haltern 70 amphorae from castro do vieito, north of portugal, and of amphora sherds from kilns in the roman provinces Hispania Baetica and Lusitania. Hyp Inter 202: 81-87
  7. Wagner FE, Wagner U, Hausler W, Costa BFO, Silva AJM (2012) International conference on the applications of Mössbauer Spectroscopy, Medellin, Colombia.
  8. Gonzales J, Gonzales C, Gonzales M (2004) Culip VIII I les amfores haltern 70. Monografias Del CASC 5: 159-164.
  9. Friederich J, Gerhard R, Krause R, Riederer J, Wagner FE, et al. (2010) Mössbauer study of Celtic pottery from bopfingen Baden-Württemberg, Germany. J Phys: Conf Series 217: 12064.

© 2020 Chryssou K. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and build upon your work non-commercially.



About Crimson

We at Crimson Publishing are a group of people with a combined passion for science and research, who wants to bring to the world a unified platform where all scientific know-how is available read more...

Leave a comment

Contact Info

  • Crimson Publishers, LLC
  • 555 Madison Avenue, 5th floor
  •     New York, NY 10022, USA
  • +1 (929) 600-8049
  • +1 (929) 447-1137
  • info@crimsonpublishers.com
  • www.crimsonpublishers.com