Active Video Games: Paving the way to Virtual Online Active Games

Although considerable research has been conducted on playing active video games (AVGs), the majority has focused on proximal play. Little has been reported on distance-based AVG play, identified in this paper as virtual online active games (VOAGs). The potential benefits of VOAGs lies in their ability to connect similar and different populations, genders and generations over the Internet for a new type of gaming in which family, friends

In essence, a VOAG is an AVG that can be played simultaneously by multiple players in different locations. This type of game would allow avatars (character depictions on screen) to be relayed from a gaming device in one location to another device in a remote location for co-operative or competitive play in real time. While VOAG play has been available since the genesis of AVGs, research on VOAGs has lagged behind AVGs played between participants in the same location (proximally).
This lack of research exists because only a few researchers have explored VOAG. This paper endeavors to illuminate the benefits of AVGs and proposes probable concurrent benefits for VOAGs while presenting suggestions for future research. Through a narrative analysis of recent AVG research, the authors present concepts on which to base future studies of VOAGs that can offer a new way to motivate body movement, encourage social interaction, enhance cognitive abilities and reduce sedentary behavior while encouraging participation between and within generations and populations. Finding relevant entertaining ways to encourage movement can help to create a populace that seeks opportunities to engage in movement throughout their life span.

Literature Review
This literature review presents relevant AVG research from a variety of populations but does not attempt to provide a comprehensive review as others have already done extensive reviews of available literature [36][37][38][39]. The purpose of this review is to identify the benefits and problems associated with AVGs so that they can be used to frame the discussion on VOAG and to provide suggestions for future VOAG research. To add clarity to the potentials of AVGs and possible potentials of VOAGs, age groups, gender, and population types are identified. The selection of these groups was guided by the groups found in existing research. Over the past decade an abundance of research has been published in regards to AVGs. The AVG research in this paper focused on recent research from the past five years (2010-2015) allowing for a contemporary treatment of the topic and a focus on the need for future research based upon the potential for VOAGs as a medium for a new way to engage in movement.

Children ages 3-14
The proclivity of children to play video games [3] may explain why so many researchers have studied the effect of AVGs in this group. Boys and girls who played AVGs with family and friends saw them as a social activity and preferred them to non-active video games [40,41]. Additional studies indicate that inactive children may be more apt to play an AVG than to participate in real life activities [42,43] possibly because of a greater perceived chance for success [44] or due to the entertainment value of an AVG. The physical activity component of AVGs is quite possibly the best studied attribute. Pre-adolescent boys expended more energy playing AVGs than when sedentary [45]. White et al. [45] found that energy expenditure was affected by the type of AVG played. For example, bowling resulted in less energy expenditure than dancing. Energy expenditure while playing AVGs is similar to light to moderate physical intensity, making them a healthier alternative to sedentary video game plays [38,46,47]. Active Healthy Kids Canada states that children can benefit from exchanging sedentary activities for AVGs which require light to moderate physical intensity [30]. In a large study of elementary aged children engaged in physical education, Sun found that prolonged use of AVGs for two semesters led to increased PA for both boys and girls [48]. These results led Sun to recommend AVGs as a possible method for enhancing PA in physical education. An investigation of middle school students showed that the use of AVGs helped children increase PA levels enough to meet regional and national standards [49]. Another investigation found that children expended more energy while playing AVGs than when resting and sedentary video game play [50].
Ladda [51] identifies a physically literate person as one who is prepared to participate in physical activity throughout their life and shows respect for self & others [52]. If children are given enjoyable, entertaining activities they will persist in their play leading to greater physical literacy [43]. In one study, 7-11 year old children actually choose AVGs for their perceived health benefits [53]. AVGs have been successfully used in weight management programs to encourage children to increase PA [54,55]. Such programs have resulted in improved Global Self-Worth scores, reduced sedentary screen time, and reduced consumption of soda [56]. AVGs are capable of producing increases in PA [19] but this capability has not translated into long term adherence to PA using AVGs or reduced body mass for healthy gamers [57,58]. Special needs populations can benefit from AVG play through the development of motor skills [30,38]. Children with cerebral palsy (CP) have shown a benefit from AVG use as a rehabilitative tool [59,60]. Children with CP and typically developing children were able to achieve similar levels of physical intensity during AVG play [34,61]. A cycling AVG showed that improvements to aerobic fitness could be achieved for children with CP [32]. Similarly, AVGs helped children with cystic fibrosis achieved light to moderate physical intensity levels [62]. Research results have also shown that AVGs can help children with developmental delays improve their gross motor skills [63]. Appropriately selected AVGs have been credited as being a low cost and easy to obtain piece of technology that can help children achieve light to moderate physical intensity [60,[64][65][66].

Adolescents ages 13-18
Some authors have found that light to moderate physical intensity levels can be reached by adolescents playing AVGs [38,47,67]. Girls who engaged in a dance AVG achieved a moderate level of physical intensity [68] while boys taking secondary physical education classes benefited from AVG play through increased aerobic capacity and enjoyment resulting in a corresponding increase in motivation to play [69]. Increased motivation to play was also noted in a study with overweight and obese African American adolescents that linked higher motivation to play to cooperative AVG game play [70]. In social settings AVGs are preferred over sedentary video games [71]. Overweight and obese participants achieved a lower BMI following AVG use [72]. Increased executive functioning (EF) skills have also been linked to AVGs for adolescents. Success and positive engagement while playing an AVG was linked to higher EF while boredom and frustration in movement activities were linked to lower EF scores in a group of African American and Hispanic adolescents [73]. Davis et al. [73] also found that exercise increased executive functioning skills. These studies correlate with a 2010 report by the Centers for Disease Control [14], which connects increased cognitive functioning improvement with physical activity [74,75].

Adults ages 18-54
Reductions in sedentary behavior were noted for young adults who played AVGs without an increase in energy consumption [47,76]. Similarly, sedentary young adults were positively motivated to move at a moderate level of intensity suggesting that AVG play is well suited to serve as an alternative to traditional moderate intensity aerobic activities [47,77]. Worley et al. [27] showed that healthy women may benefit from AVG play by increasing oxygen and caloric demands. University students who are inactive prefer AVGs to the activities offered in Physical Education courses [78]. In a comparison between AVGs and DVD recorded exercise routines, Limperos [79] found that groups of participants viewed AVGs as more motivating and easier to play. When a video game is perceived as an easy to use game and not as a learning task, players are more motivated to engage the game [80]. AVGs that prompt players with an intent to exercise over the intent to play a game can produce more perseverance and longer playing times [81]. However, the emphasis on the health aspects of the game should not override the entertainment value of the game as exercise AVGs that lack entertainment value are less motivating to the players [82]. Obese individuals were motivated to move at a moderate to vigorous level of physical intensity by playing AVGs [83,84]. Participants work harder for less perceived effort when they play with a partner virtually over the Internet [85]. These virtual Internet partners can improve the effort and duration of less able partners by their virtual presence and distant silent partner avatars may be able to provide a better form of feedback for increasing length of play than a partner who provides verbal feedback [85,86].
Balance improvement and injury preventions are identified as benefits of AVG balance programs for college students [87]. As for the development of certain motor skills, AVGs have been found to help adults to improve their balance as well [88]. Hurkmans et al. [88] and van den Berg-Emons et al. [89] investigated how adults who suffer from chronic strokes could benefit from AVG play and found that they increased their energy expenditure while playing an AVG. Adults with CP have also been found to increase their physical intensity to a moderate level while playing an AVG [90].

Adults older than 55
Of all generations, older adults are getting the least amount of PA [91]. Recent statistics have shown that only 12% of older adults are getting enough strength training for muscle and bone health and only 11% get enough aerobic activity [92]. This is unfortunate because even moderate levels of PA can help older adults avoid some chronic diseases [93]. In addition to inadequate levels of PA, older adults may also experience social isolation from family and friends [94]. Isolation in older adults can affect physical and mental health resulting in less motivation to engage in movement activities resulting in a negative response to exercise [94]. Older adults were found to be more motivated to exercise and displayed positive gains in socialization following AVG play [95]. The social benefits of such games, for this age group, are evidenced by increased participant enjoyment [96]. It is suggested that innovations are needed to help older adults access and maintain healthy levels of PA [97]. A group of elderly adult subjects were judged to be less likely to fall and exhibit improved health following AVG balance activities [29]. In a similar study AVGs were found to have potential to improve balance when balance was impaired [98]. AVGs have been successful in allowing participants to increase their physical intensity to a light level while seated or while standing [35]. Research has also shown that older adults who are undergoing physical therapy following total knee replacements may use AVGs as acceptable additions to traditional rehabilitative treatments as long as they involve balance for the lower extremities [99].

AVG Strengths Point to VOAG Potential
There are several researched benefits of AVGs that point to the possible efficacy of VOAGs. Players enjoy AVGs that are competitive or cooperative based upon their personalities [100]. When the AVG type matches the players' preference for task completion they can become more engaged in the PA. Nickel [101] posits that a balance needs to be struck between the cognitive and physical aspect of AVGs so that players receive an appropriately challenging experience that they can achieve given their present skill levels.
Research results have shown that AVGs deemed more fun increase the length of participation and energy expenditure during AVG play [102]. When PA is viewed as entertaining, doable, relevant, and enjoyable, players enter into a flow state that result in increased energy expenditure and less perceived effort [103,104]. VOAGs allow for cooperative and competitive play over the Internet with others players enabling participants to engage in PA that expands the pool of participants from proximal to an online community of participants thereby increasing opportunities for participation. AVGs allow players to enter virtual worlds, helping them into flow while playing [105,106]. Flow Theory relates to a participants persistence to play [105]. Persistence to play is directly related to the enjoyment levels of the participants. This enjoyment can be gauged by a voluntary desire to play and continued desire to engage in physical activities that are driven by technology [104,105]. VOAGs have the added advantage of providing participants with connections to other persons through the Internet increasing chances for PA in a motivating virtual environment even when no one is proximally present to engage them in movement activities.
AVGs use avatars to simulate players on the screen which may benefit those who have body image dissatisfaction by providing players with an alternate view of self while they play [100]. Individuals adhering to a negative body image expressed less anxiety when playing an AVG compared to subjects with a positive body image [100]. The use of typically developed body size avatars can help to overcome the lowered desire to move accompanied by the stigma of overweight images [107]. These findings correlate well with additional research which found that participants who more closely associate with their avatar are more motivated to play [108]. Taken together these three studies shed important light on the effect of screen avatars in AVGs. Avatars that positively enhance the image of a player have the potential to increase the benefit of AVG play for overweight and obese players. The virtual nature of VOAGs assures that the benefits mentioned above will also be present for VOAG participants. Technology for improved AVG input allows for game mechanics to more closely resemble real life tasks providing an important bridge between game play and actual movement experiences [101]. This is accomplished when input devices relate absolute position of body parts, such as a camera and infrared sensors that track movement, and not simply relative positions, such as handheld or foot activated input devices [109]. One study found that children with high real life gross motor scores were more successful while playing AVGs [110]. This may indicate a possible positive relationship between improvement in input devices and improvements in player gross motor skills. Another found that differing input devices can be effective when engaging in a VOAG [111].
AVG play lends itself well to use by special populations. Recent research shows that people who are overweight/obese [85], have low body image [100], lack confidence [112], have physical disabilities [90], need rehabilitation activities [30], may all benefit from playing AVGs. One group of researchers studied AVG play between typically developing peers and people with disabilities in wheelchairs and found that wheelchair subjects could participate on par with those who were not in a wheelchair [112]. An activity that allows for enjoyable, engaging energy expenditure for both typically developing and disabled participants shows promise for increased understanding between subjects as well as improved self-esteem for persons with special needs [112]. Persons with disabilities are often isolated by their disability. VOAGs offer this population an opportunity to participate with others over the Internet virtually and show promise for their ability to provide differentiated participation [112].
Some feel AVGs should be used only for the introductory phases of PA training [113]. These investigators state that actual sports will produce more physical intensity than AVGs. A different group of researchers suggest that AVGs can produce an amount of physical intensity similar to that of the actual activity [113,114]. This group of researchers state that AVGs may serve as acceptable replacements for traditional activities aimed at increasing physical activities. Persons who are overweight, obese, and have special needs are drawn to virtual PA positioning VOAG play as a way to increase participation among persons in these populations. AVGs are attractive to players of both genders [115]. The ability of AVGs to motivate girls is important because during the transition from adolescence to young adulthood there is a measureable decline in vigorous movement and strengthening activities amongst girls [116]. This may be due, in part, to the view that girls see themselves as less capable on physical tasks which are competitive in nature; often the core of activities offered in physical education classes [117]. This low view of self has been linked to an increase in the amount of excess weight put on by young women [118]. Given an opportunity to engage in VOAGs female participants may engage the activity with an increased desire to move due to less perceived inequality between participants.

VOAG Research
While many studies have endeavored to point out the benefits and limitations of AVGs few have taken a look at VOAG those that have point to some encouraging correlations between AVGs and VOAGs. Some have even identified VOAGs for their unique effects on the PA of those who engage them. VOAGs have the ability to link two individuals for competitive, collaborative, or cooperative play over the internet. The Kőhler effect describes the increased effort in less able group members to keep up with the more skilled members of the group. Whilst game system generated non-player characters can elicit the Kőhler effect, stronger Kőhler effect results from play between partners who are thought to be human [119,120]. Peng & Crouse [121] agree that parallel play with another human in a different location is preferred to parallel play in proximity to another human. Similar results were recorded when investigators found that the presence of a proximal peer actually decreased the subjects motivation to play an AVG over a sedentary video game [18]. Additional research shows that heterogenous input devices may be used in VOAG play while retaining social benefits [112]. These intriguing results point to the importance of new VOAG studies to leverage this phenomenon.
VOAGs were studied for their effect on the physical, social, emotional and cognitive changes in secondary physical education students. The results of the research showed that the students enjoyed playing with another student over the Internet more than with a game generated non-player character [122]. Cognitive functioning was increased as measured by executive functioning skills while playing non-player characters and virtually playing another student over the Internet [123]. Motivation to participate was greater for play with another student virtually over the Internet [124]. Heart rate increased more while students engaged another student virtually over the Internet [125]. These initial studies need to be expanded to other generations and within and between other populations such as overweight/obese, special needs, elderly, female and differing social economic groups.

Suggestions for Future VOAG Research
Although recent research on AVGs is plentiful, in this article we attempted to show that research on VOAGs is still needed. This paper endeavored to present a review of the researched efficacy of AVGs and showed that VOAG play has also been linked to similar results while highlighting the need for future research. VOAGs present opportunities for participation between populations, genders, and generations that are not indicated by AVG research.

Copyright © Brian Kooiman
AVGs can be enhanced through internet connections. VOAG play can be beneficial to a variety of groups of people, such as family and children who are separated by distance (i.e.) military personnel, those detained in correctional facilities or when grandparents cannot be with their grandchildren. Likewise, absent parents who must travel or who no longer live with their children may benefit from VOAG play. Additionally, people who lack mobility yet want social interaction; those who prefer the familiarity and security of their own homes yet need encouragement from other players; overweight and obese people who may not enjoy exercising in public but like knowing that others are exercising alongside them; or special needs populations with differing skill levels can all connect for VOAG activities. The VOAG experience may help to make lifelong movers out of increasing numbers of people helping to meet the need for meaningful movement activities that help us connect for play with others in new and relevant ways. The increased motivation that accompanies playing with family and friends, and desire to play longer for less perceived effort, coupled with a need for ways to connect for physical, emotional, social and cognitive play when separated by distance all point to the possible benefit of VOAGs.